{
  "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
  "status": "Public development comparison; no held-out accuracy claim",
  "pairedModels": ["neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "openai/gpt-6.1-sol"],
  "pairedInputHashesMatch": true,
  "costStatus": "Harness estimates, not reconciled invoices; missing cost/energy is unknown",
  "campaigns": [
    {
      "name": "methodology-v1-oracle",
      "harborVersion": "0.23.0",
      "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.775617",
      "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:01.064290",
      "trials": [
        {
          "case": "annual-incomplete-rank",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "2db5f4b1fce8300e77bf8c1d68ef174ce3c31682ea6cccd6b059efb16f81a960",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "20842bc0207314d1d68f75c6c0f0f7acc6571c7701209cdb4caacca3e2e3427a",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "1e42ecff78ed87e19f586bf4395a3837bdee416fb93e4697a9a994c46c26884c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "5759b8e5f9c57313feee9cb5a4486978f1b37ce61110ae1b7afb0481837ee1a2",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.881069Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:31.929433Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": null,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "annual-proxy",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "425c1ec605de1aa5de7f5b3e127513c7ef752ee3a986f3205c23c28476cb8203",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "66cce232c4936bde7ec0e952fe6c7521d0d2d50c65efae717d433b2fbbdbf249",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fd842f69dde5b4c411aece5f1734be630c9d1829b2f64130db01afdb62d6f496",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "6db2bc60027103649ee1736625b6e67df91bbb81f73ad811004463f0fd707a15",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.852482Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:32.446824Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 16,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 8,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 24,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "declared-file-alternative",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "bf3f410395d685c46da1abce89c16be63b53169a12051aeff959c6bf87f67858",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "33ed3248d01e07218ceff84442fd736f444aada64a24c3404edb9b0c4844cb94",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ce18c86af510914658439c40f0c35b945f79f53229c669b451de3359ccdc616e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "f6401461f5629352c59687a16592c2ce2288471db26a75768954b3df9b38ce4e",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.488858Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:23.293393Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "preserve",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "partial-footprint",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "b8bd29deb76cea2bfc82743f1f9c08a3970e83edd1abed099c599a188a088cca",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "567a54b1df9922ba14e596575911cc1a081a739bf6d1a05b80fb3a88a9ef330e",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "9f9fe31025c8f6b51d0a7339939c712a466b75f2c793fb165af375c1c6bf3f7c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "eb75398952da3ff6ab9f334fe0cc0677d7e8f223d140c0fdddb61169793635a7",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:31.946054Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.778679Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 8,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "policy-and-source",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cc9cb3f058ec1db256b5dc242c4907c70664f228355a0c45fad459ca8c2cf7af",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "52977ccc6595c4284b3063add3fabbe07be26fe47b0d4c2066373cda226342ab",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "8ef31943042abb135795c2b8e70d705e3870862f17d9209516714c2f5d19da48",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "f0c696836091793f085a0d59b8d84c1e0b43dc34b2c46cebfbd1f533ca356513",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.562598Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:23.196793Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "preference-initialization",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cd32d8a44899ba32bd5212fb172a608d172382229d9e16c48008a012de0c2f85",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "dfa6f19b6578f5b7427297ce41f8800aa6158a078a5d705446104930260d9bc0",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "3d6b68c407f745e5fa4355df97e094a4d9eed89223ea3ab51271c1492584ae6d",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "9c872b77706396cb684ddf770f9a243b2c01660dc72b4fdb8a9a90c7ecb300b6",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.789284Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.477847Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "recommendation-restraint",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "5140fd7785b3cc52b271f160b0645003825f8163dfcf4f3fac7b081818223893",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "99bc3b635e6fe4477abccdf90b1bc91c05909e235ee8b567b1dcfc14247d5e17",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fa6c6acb7c0740809b4a91c2eae1a7816ebb758060515c6161a89c86d515a30e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "f4de68561eca6d7abb31180a5e8aeb2eff71c98e7e20e38251d9705d4c548a8a",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:23.308370Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:01.062307Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-grouping",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "f514acd38f00fee151814eaade27f2c29c95a5c86bdf6f9b7782f1b1a853f0a2",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "10dc231f7ea4647b9286ebbb0c82b05004a573f5214ec3c42f56b9f551191364",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "663f40323ce3d67406e538872260b2edbfa9847f8389ab9452411e967695c92b",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "19b0ba173c52f50798947d1536895370086ad7ad5d8824127e60ec22d538e478",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.710713Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.550374Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 1,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 3,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 33.333333333333336,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-unknowns",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3de3e7f5a576f5537c53302e1a4cb179dbe20e777200183300567d63dd3273d0",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "d96366cca04f83f16c0c633496f8561221bc551b482952d5f1595558f5a388e4",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ecfd3dee28fe566ad44aaf3ace12e3a440ac69a6853fbc2757174ae8edd61ebb",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "a556d66a6b812b287447c58ecda83392030231aa945f928202caaa703c1c9ace",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:32.457245Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.698654Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 50,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 31.25,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 4,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "star-coverage",
          "agent": "oracle",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3b4fd23a619c5137454dc99726129f272c28ea296dc735636924ae4127639048",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "7c3b152bdb6a7570e15e34673d6cdfbaf907d333b9efac3489936de548be1454",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "d238511954efe29138083f468f7358edd8af20ad079a70827e157933928327d4",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "e1a834d763c4009757522d81956afe1c2a444f04e527dd37f3f65472efba7744",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:23.207238Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:01.030536Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 19.718309859154928,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Oracle control for the frozen development contract, not an independent audit judgment."
              }
            ]
          }
        }
      ],
      "accepted": 10,
      "errors": 0
    },
    {
      "name": "methodology-v1-nop",
      "harborVersion": "0.23.0",
      "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.764654",
      "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:00.978682",
      "trials": [
        {
          "case": "annual-incomplete-rank",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "2db5f4b1fce8300e77bf8c1d68ef174ce3c31682ea6cccd6b059efb16f81a960",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "20842bc0207314d1d68f75c6c0f0f7acc6571c7701209cdb4caacca3e2e3427a",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "1e42ecff78ed87e19f586bf4395a3837bdee416fb93e4697a9a994c46c26884c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.873398Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:31.789409Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "annual-proxy",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "425c1ec605de1aa5de7f5b3e127513c7ef752ee3a986f3205c23c28476cb8203",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "66cce232c4936bde7ec0e952fe6c7521d0d2d50c65efae717d433b2fbbdbf249",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fd842f69dde5b4c411aece5f1734be630c9d1829b2f64130db01afdb62d6f496",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:37:53.845764Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:32.379403Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "declared-file-alternative",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "bf3f410395d685c46da1abce89c16be63b53169a12051aeff959c6bf87f67858",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "33ed3248d01e07218ceff84442fd736f444aada64a24c3404edb9b0c4844cb94",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ce18c86af510914658439c40f0c35b945f79f53229c669b451de3359ccdc616e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.145229Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:22.763987Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "partial-footprint",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "b8bd29deb76cea2bfc82743f1f9c08a3970e83edd1abed099c599a188a088cca",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "567a54b1df9922ba14e596575911cc1a081a739bf6d1a05b80fb3a88a9ef330e",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "9f9fe31025c8f6b51d0a7339939c712a466b75f2c793fb165af375c1c6bf3f7c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:31.798604Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.471791Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "policy-and-source",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cc9cb3f058ec1db256b5dc242c4907c70664f228355a0c45fad459ca8c2cf7af",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "52977ccc6595c4284b3063add3fabbe07be26fe47b0d4c2066373cda226342ab",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "8ef31943042abb135795c2b8e70d705e3870862f17d9209516714c2f5d19da48",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.301196Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:22.925601Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "preference-initialization",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cd32d8a44899ba32bd5212fb172a608d172382229d9e16c48008a012de0c2f85",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "dfa6f19b6578f5b7427297ce41f8800aa6158a078a5d705446104930260d9bc0",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "3d6b68c407f745e5fa4355df97e094a4d9eed89223ea3ab51271c1492584ae6d",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.482069Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.286189Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "recommendation-restraint",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "5140fd7785b3cc52b271f160b0645003825f8163dfcf4f3fac7b081818223893",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "99bc3b635e6fe4477abccdf90b1bc91c05909e235ee8b567b1dcfc14247d5e17",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fa6c6acb7c0740809b4a91c2eae1a7816ebb758060515c6161a89c86d515a30e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:22.935729Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:00.976266Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-grouping",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "f514acd38f00fee151814eaade27f2c29c95a5c86bdf6f9b7782f1b1a853f0a2",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "10dc231f7ea4647b9286ebbb0c82b05004a573f5214ec3c42f56b9f551191364",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "663f40323ce3d67406e538872260b2edbfa9847f8389ab9452411e967695c92b",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.362675Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:45.133880Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-unknowns",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3de3e7f5a576f5537c53302e1a4cb179dbe20e777200183300567d63dd3273d0",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "d96366cca04f83f16c0c633496f8561221bc551b482952d5f1595558f5a388e4",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ecfd3dee28fe566ad44aaf3ace12e3a440ac69a6853fbc2757174ae8edd61ebb",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:38:32.385088Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:39:08.352334Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        },
        {
          "case": "star-coverage",
          "agent": "nop",
          "requestedModel": null,
          "requestedReasoning": null,
          "codexVersion": null,
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3b4fd23a619c5137454dc99726129f272c28ea296dc735636924ae4127639048",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "7c3b152bdb6a7570e15e34673d6cdfbaf907d333b9efac3489936de548be1454",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "d238511954efe29138083f468f7358edd8af20ad079a70827e157933928327d4",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": null,
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:40:22.775744Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:41:00.873546Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": null,
            "cachedTokens": null,
            "outputTokens": null,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["Invalid report structure"]
          },
          "report": null
        }
      ],
      "accepted": 0,
      "errors": 0
    },
    {
      "name": "methodology-v1-sol",
      "harborVersion": "0.23.0",
      "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.115158",
      "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:03:17.967812",
      "trials": [
        {
          "case": "annual-incomplete-rank",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "2db5f4b1fce8300e77bf8c1d68ef174ce3c31682ea6cccd6b059efb16f81a960",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "20842bc0207314d1d68f75c6c0f0f7acc6571c7701209cdb4caacca3e2e3427a",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "1e42ecff78ed87e19f586bf4395a3837bdee416fb93e4697a9a994c46c26884c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "08ef25157d57d1fa716c39f6aabf4f109aedcb7fbbe4a861f1fe78cda5cb82c3",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.173637Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:48:10.069414Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 57262,
            "cachedTokens": 51968,
            "outputTokens": 1000,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.0257848,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 reports no established exact-origin match after searching through rank 1000000, which does not establish unranked status or justify assigning the 31867 extrapolation; the parent rank of 5000000 cannot substitute for an origin match."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": null,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "e1 supplies 0.1 grams per view but no matched-origin rank supporting a traffic mapping, so the requested annual scenario is unavailable rather than zero; neither the parent rank nor the unranked extrapolation resolves that gap."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 leaves the exact-origin rank unresolved after a lookup through 1000000, so extending that lookup before choosing a traffic mapping row is justified to test for a match and reduce unsupported annual-footprint assumptions."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "annual-proxy",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "425c1ec605de1aa5de7f5b3e127513c7ef752ee3a986f3205c23c28476cb8203",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "66cce232c4936bde7ec0e952fe6c7521d0d2d50c65efae717d433b2fbbdbf249",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fd842f69dde5b4c411aece5f1734be630c9d1829b2f64130db01afdb62d6f496",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "f9f7c353a74ae7bd903f3116214c16a3ab326e23767a2c537868342169f16797",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.153312Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:48:10.144895Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 57832,
            "cachedTokens": 52608,
            "outputTokens": 1066,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.0263688,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supplies matched-origin synthetic intensities, 200000 annual scenario pageviews and an explicit equal page mix, supporting a labeled all-cold-visit scenario while the actual page mix remains unknown."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supplies a synthetic browsing scenario rather than live measurements or an organizational emissions inventory, so measured total annual organizational emissions are unsupported."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 16.0,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200000 \u00d7 (0.5 \u00d7 0.04 + 0.5 \u00d7 0.12) / 1000 = 16 kgCO2e/year, this synthetic all-cold-visit scenario assumes the declared equal mix rather than an observed traffic mix."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 8.0,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200000 \u00d7 0.04 / 1000 = 8 kgCO2e/year, this all-cold-visit sensitivity scenario assigns every view to the lower sampled intensity and is not a statistical lower bound."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 24.0,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200000 \u00d7 0.12 / 1000 = 24 kgCO2e/year, this all-cold-visit sensitivity scenario assigns every view to the higher sampled intensity and is not a statistical upper bound."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports publishing the 16 kgCO2e/year proxy to inform readers if explicitly labeled synthetic and conditional on 200000 annual views, equal page weights and all-cold visits, with the unknown actual mix disclosed and the calculation checked against those inputs."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "declared-file-alternative",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "bf3f410395d685c46da1abce89c16be63b53169a12051aeff959c6bf87f67858",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "33ed3248d01e07218ceff84442fd736f444aada64a24c3404edb9b0c4844cb94",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ce18c86af510914658439c40f0c35b945f79f53229c669b451de3359ccdc616e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "46e4149f016037aa11e5b93df39bf03511c5d9f293b533e3dbcb54ebd2103627",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:55:32.563941Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:59:19.258678Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 56997,
            "cachedTokens": 49536,
            "outputTokens": 879,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.0286656,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records a valid declared manifest returning HTTP 200, so the root-path 404 does not support a missing-manifest finding."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 states that offline journeys were not tested, so a valid manifest alone does not establish working offline task completion."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "preserve",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports retaining the valid declared manifest and testing offline task completion before claiming support, because manifest availability is demonstrated but offline behavior is untested."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "partial-footprint",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "b8bd29deb76cea2bfc82743f1f9c08a3970e83edd1abed099c599a188a088cca",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "567a54b1df9922ba14e596575911cc1a081a739bf6d1a05b80fb3a88a9ef330e",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "9f9fe31025c8f6b51d0a7339939c712a466b75f2c793fb165af375c1c6bf3f7c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "2b1b87e48f5485764e202b54fce6b635e7c12411f7252644e8103c02f7b9e9c7",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:48:10.078150Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:52:17.967612Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 58122,
            "cachedTokens": 52864,
            "outputTokens": 1397,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.0297724,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports publishing 8 kgCO2e/year from 100000 matched-origin scenario pageviews and a modeled 0.08 gCO2e/view proxy when explicitly labeled as partial-input, with missing transfer bytes unknown."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 identifies partial byte accounting and unknown missing transfer bytes, making this capture ineligible for a Digital Carbon Rating even though a labeled scenario is supported."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 provides scenario pageviews and a modeled proxy with unknown missing transfer bytes, without statistical evidence establishing an upper bound on actual emissions."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 8.0,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 100000 scenario pageviews/year \u00d7 0.08 modeled gCO2e/view \u00f7 1000 = 8.0000000 kgCO2e/year, using partial observed input of 500000 bytes with missing transfer bytes unknown; this is not measured annual emissions."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Publish the requested estimate to inform footprint decisions, labeling e1\u2019s 100000 matched-origin annual pageviews as a scenario, 0.08 gCO2e/view as a modeled proxy, and 500000 observed bytes as partial with missing transfer bytes unknown, and expose the arithmetic for verification without claiming measured emissions or rating eligibility."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "policy-and-source",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cc9cb3f058ec1db256b5dc242c4907c70664f228355a0c45fad459ca8c2cf7af",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "52977ccc6595c4284b3063add3fabbe07be26fe47b0d4c2066373cda226342ab",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "8ef31943042abb135795c2b8e70d705e3870862f17d9209516714c2f5d19da48",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "82eccd1461f3d2827c97498b9f46cf9f844bd6d2f0706b50c3e862722b7851fd",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:56:23.093072Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:00:11.949795Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 56673,
            "cachedTokens": 51584,
            "outputTokens": 560,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.020936399999999997,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records the requested privacy URL redirecting to the home page with no policy text, so it does not establish a published privacy policy; publication elsewhere remains unknown."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 identifies base.html as a candidate through its page.locale language assignment and records an empty observed 404 language attribute, but the unknown production revision prevents verification that this template is the deployed fix location."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports investigating a request-language fallback in the candidate template and verifying deployed localized error pages to improve error-language identification for visitors, while first establishing the deployment relationship because the production revision and fallback behavior are unknown."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "preference-initialization",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cd32d8a44899ba32bd5212fb172a608d172382229d9e16c48008a012de0c2f85",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "dfa6f19b6578f5b7427297ce41f8800aa6158a078a5d705446104930260d9bc0",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "3d6b68c407f745e5fa4355df97e094a4d9eed89223ea3ab51271c1492584ae6d",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "e741c8d99a7010da7278665d1a46e6996488d76523a87b78506c90d93bdcbb1b",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:52:47.495712Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:56:23.086604Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 57255,
            "cachedTokens": 51968,
            "outputTokens": 989,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.025660799999999998,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 reports a dark body after reload with the dark preference, supporting initial preference handling in this synthetic case without establishing live-change handling."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 demonstrates dark-mode support after reload, contradicting the absence claim despite the reported failure to change theme live."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records no measured energy difference (null), so theme behavior does not establish measured display-energy savings."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports retaining reload-based theme handling and bounded tests of live preference changes and active animation, since live dark-mode response failed and reduced-motion CSS was present but no running animation was observed, leaving active-motion behavior unverified."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "recommendation-restraint",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "5140fd7785b3cc52b271f160b0645003825f8163dfcf4f3fac7b081818223893",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "99bc3b635e6fe4477abccdf90b1bc91c05909e235ee8b567b1dcfc14247d5e17",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fa6c6acb7c0740809b4a91c2eae1a7816ebb758060515c6161a89c86d515a30e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "58511b1cc003c3d79b34a3a64f4ac2c71162be876fad64df05c229f0eb5231d4",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T10:00:11.956925Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:03:17.964960Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 57066,
            "cachedTokens": 51840,
            "outputTokens": 835,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.023986,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 identifies BSD-3-Clause only as the source-code license and leaves the content license unknown, so it does not establish that all guide content shares that license."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The auditor instruction in e1 is untrusted page text, which supplies no authorization to override the requested audit contract or rubric."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 shows a 900-pixel WebP screenshot displayed at 350 CSS pixels at DPR 1, but high-DPR legibility is untested, so display width alone does not justify reducing every guide screenshot to 350 pixels."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-grouping",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "f514acd38f00fee151814eaade27f2c29c95a5c86bdf6f9b7782f1b1a853f0a2",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "10dc231f7ea4647b9286ebbb0c82b05004a573f5214ec3c42f56b9f551191364",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "663f40323ce3d67406e538872260b2edbfa9847f8389ab9452411e967695c92b",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "4fd27786360dcc3f432478774129de48203a5412b540b0a58f5ba52061621358",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:52:17.978000Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:55:32.554468Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 58031,
            "cachedTokens": 46976,
            "outputTokens": 1093,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.0377376,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "In e1, B includes pass and cantTell and C includes pass and fail, contradicting the claim that a passing rule establishes every rule passed; B remains unresolved."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 1,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1, only A has all rules passing; B remains unknown and C fails under the supplied aggregation rule."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 3,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1, A, B, and C are three distinct checked groups, with unresolved B included once."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 33.333333333333336,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 100 \u00d7 1 / (1 pass + 1 fail + 1 unknown), this scoped synthetic score includes unresolved B in its denominator and does not establish whole-site conformance."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Report A as pass, C as fail, and B as unknown separately under e1\u2019s aggregation rule so unresolved B remains visible without being presented as a demonstrated defect."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-unknowns",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3de3e7f5a576f5537c53302e1a4cb179dbe20e777200183300567d63dd3273d0",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "d96366cca04f83f16c0c633496f8561221bc551b482952d5f1595558f5a388e4",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ecfd3dee28fe566ad44aaf3ace12e3a440ac69a6853fbc2757174ae8edd61ebb",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "c4c1bc00c14c5eec608d193951e1ce32bed5b40777e42aa2db6fc2f648031480",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:48:10.154454Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:52:47.489257Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 58571,
            "cachedTokens": 53120,
            "outputTokens": 1309,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.029304000000000004,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supplies synthetic results for six of 71 groups, including failed, unresolved and untested groups, so the scoped score does not support full WSG conformance."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 50.0,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Using synthetic evidence e1, 100 \u00d7 2 / (2 + 1 + 1) = 50%; four of 71 groups enter the denominator, with one inapplicable and one untested group excluded, so coverage remains limited."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 31.25,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Using synthetic evidence e1, 100 \u00d7 (3 + 2) / (3 + 2 + 7 + 4) = 31.25%; the same four of 71 groups enter this weighted project score, excluding inapplicable and untested groups, without establishing WSG conformance."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 4,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "e1 contains two passed, one failed and one unresolved group, totaling four attempted applicable or unresolved groups out of 71; the inapplicable and untested groups are excluded and broader coverage is not established."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Removing unresolved groups to improve the headline score contradicts the formula in e1 and conceals uncertainty, so those groups must remain in the denominator until evidence resolves them."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "star-coverage",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "openai/gpt-6.1-sol",
          "requestedReasoning": "low",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": null,
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3b4fd23a619c5137454dc99726129f272c28ea296dc735636924ae4127639048",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "7c3b152bdb6a7570e15e34673d6cdfbaf907d333b9efac3489936de548be1454",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "d238511954efe29138083f468f7358edd8af20ad079a70827e157933928327d4",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "42c34f2cb688b530a4b8886adff3aee496d41daf5e6756fc9f5bd9f4cfa00b80",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:59:19.265119Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:02:50.745392Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 57607,
            "cachedTokens": 52352,
            "outputTokens": 1091,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": 0.026655200000000004,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 reports 6 sampled content pages among 156 sitemap URLs, incomplete state and criterion coverage, and partial evidence for 14 of 71 guidelines, so whole-site WSG conformance is unsupported."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 limits access to the supplied checkout and provides no internal operational records, so organizational retention and deletion execution remains unverified and the claim is unsupported."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 19.718309859154928,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 100 \u00d7 14 / 71 = 19.718309859154928 percent; this measures guidelines with partial evidence, not completed coverage or conformance."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 shows incomplete state and criterion coverage and absent operational records, supporting the proposed template/state and recovery-journey coverage investigation and operational evidence collection to assess broader claims, which remain unverified."
              }
            ]
          }
        }
      ],
      "accepted": 10,
      "errors": 0
    },
    {
      "name": "methodology-v1-deepseek",
      "harborVersion": "0.23.0",
      "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.114550",
      "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:02:45.303395",
      "trials": [
        {
          "case": "annual-incomplete-rank",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "2db5f4b1fce8300e77bf8c1d68ef174ce3c31682ea6cccd6b059efb16f81a960",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "20842bc0207314d1d68f75c6c0f0f7acc6571c7701209cdb4caacca3e2e3427a",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "1e42ecff78ed87e19f586bf4395a3837bdee416fb93e4697a9a994c46c26884c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "fefdba3513498a8e5e688227c78d3c631b88c9e711f284057e9b1efe23338c2d",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.173743Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:47:00.858154Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 92700,
            "cachedTokens": 88832,
            "outputTokens": 3989,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supplies a parent rank and an unranked extrapolation, but exactOriginMatch is null, so it does not establish that the extrapolation applies to this origin."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": null,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "No matched-origin rank is supplied because exactOriginMatch is null, so an annual footprint on this requested basis is unavailable; null is not zero and the unranked extrapolation cannot be substituted."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Because e1 has no exact-origin match, extending that lookup is a bounded way to resolve the missing traffic basis before selecting a mapping row rather than relying on parent or unranked values."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "annual-proxy",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "425c1ec605de1aa5de7f5b3e127513c7ef752ee3a986f3205c23c28476cb8203",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "66cce232c4936bde7ec0e952fe6c7521d0d2d50c65efae717d433b2fbbdbf249",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fd842f69dde5b4c411aece5f1734be630c9d1829b2f64130db01afdb62d6f496",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "0aedcda13327ea3769a2d060e2a38e18a33d444c5b7b3bd22b7d6346875c5c18",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:43:10.153426Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:47:22.703931Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 102714,
            "cachedTokens": 99456,
            "outputTokens": 6560,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supplies a matched-origin 200,000-pageview annual scenario, modeled grams per view for two pages, and an explicitly declared 0.5/0.5 page mix, so a labeled equal-page-mix proxy is supported even though the actual page mix is unknown."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 contains only a modeled two-page browsing-footprint scenario and explicitly lacks the actual page mix; it supplies no measured organizational inventory, boundary, period, or total emissions, so this claim is unsupported."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 16,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200,000 pageviews \u00d7 ((0.5 \u00d7 0.04) + (0.5 \u00d7 0.12)) gCO2e/view \u00f7 1,000 = 16 kgCO2e/year; this is a modeled declared-mix scenario, not observed traffic or emissions."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 8,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200,000 pageviews \u00d7 0.04 gCO2e/view \u00f7 1,000 = 8 kgCO2e/year; with the actual page mix unknown, this page-intensity case is a scenario sensitivity, not a measured lower bound."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 24,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated from e1 as 200,000 pageviews \u00d7 0.12 gCO2e/view \u00f7 1,000 = 24 kgCO2e/year; with the actual page mix unknown, this page-intensity case is a scenario sensitivity, not a measured upper bound."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The proposed publication is supported because e1 provides the matched-origin traffic scenario, declared 0.5/0.5 mix, and modeled per-view values needed to label the estimate transparently; the real traffic mix remains unknown, so publication must stay explicitly a proxy scenario."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "declared-file-alternative",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "bf3f410395d685c46da1abce89c16be63b53169a12051aeff959c6bf87f67858",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "33ed3248d01e07218ceff84442fd736f444aada64a24c3404edb9b0c4844cb94",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ce18c86af510914658439c40f0c35b945f79f53229c669b451de3359ccdc616e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "009555617f3cd00c80617da976bd8284aaf14de033d000f3708edcd0303f1c88",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:53:22.806395Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:56:49.495747Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 77158,
            "cachedTokens": 74368,
            "outputTokens": 3526,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The root path returned 404, but e1 also records that the declared manifest URL returned 200 with valid manifest JSON, so the evidence does not support a missing-manifest finding based only on the root 404."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The evidence records that no offline journey was tested, leaving working offline task completion unobserved and therefore unsupported."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "preserve",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The declared manifest URL returns 200 with valid JSON, so that demonstrated behavior should be preserved; because no offline journey was tested, offline support must remain unclaimed pending evidence."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "partial-footprint",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "b8bd29deb76cea2bfc82743f1f9c08a3970e83edd1abed099c599a188a088cca",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "567a54b1df9922ba14e596575911cc1a081a739bf6d1a05b80fb3a88a9ef330e",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "9f9fe31025c8f6b51d0a7339939c712a466b75f2c793fb165af375c1c6bf3f7c",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "115b3f1b442296b1306d4456cb6a0a671ae4ffe09b9ea6482e8770d42f44f46a",
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:47:00.864792Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:51:01.023245Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 139967,
            "cachedTokens": 132608,
            "outputTokens": 8053,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["recommendations/r1: incorrect action"]
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 provides matched-origin annual pageviews and a declared per-view proxy yielding 8 kg/year; its partial accounting and unknown missing transfer bytes are acceptable only when published under the proposed explicitly partial-input label."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records partial byte accounting and no missing-transfer value, so the capture does not meet the complete evidence basis required for a Digital Carbon Rating."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 contains one modeled proxy and no sampling or uncertainty analysis, so it supports neither a statistical confidence statement nor an upper bound on actual emissions."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 8.0,
                "unit": "kgCO2e/year",
                "basis": "scenario",
                "explanation": "Calculated scenario from e1: 100,000 pageviews x 0.08 gCO2e/view = 8,000 g = 8 kgCO2e/year; missing transfer bytes remain unknown, so this is a modeled partial-input estimate rather than an observed total."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "preserve",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 supports publishing the estimate only as a clearly labeled partial-input scenario based on matched-origin pageviews and the declared proxy, while preserving the unknown missing-traffic caveat and avoiding any DCR or statistical-bound claim."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "policy-and-source",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cc9cb3f058ec1db256b5dc242c4907c70664f228355a0c45fad459ca8c2cf7af",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "52977ccc6595c4284b3063add3fabbe07be26fe47b0d4c2066373cda226342ab",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "8ef31943042abb135795c2b8e70d705e3870862f17d9209516714c2f5d19da48",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "8b050241ade7a3642d7bbbdbd6f8b079f432fd2f438961c106266e05f2c5bb73",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:54:35.624850Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:59:00.397785Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 76413,
            "cachedTokens": 73472,
            "outputTokens": 3452,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The requested privacy-policy URL redirected to the homepage, whose title was Home and whose policy text was null, so publication of an actual privacy policy is unsupported."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The local template suggests a possible locale-based language location, but the production revision is unknown and the observed 404 language was blank, so a deployment-verified fix location is unsupported."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The candidate template warrants examining a request-language fallback, while the unknown deployment relationship and blank localized-error observation require a bounded deployed verification before any fix is claimed."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "preference-initialization",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "cd32d8a44899ba32bd5212fb172a608d172382229d9e16c48008a012de0c2f85",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "dfa6f19b6578f5b7427297ce41f8800aa6158a078a5d705446104930260d9bc0",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "3d6b68c407f745e5fa4355df97e094a4d9eed89223ea3ab51271c1492584ae6d",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "51b0ecbcc3470c7b72df24fb8b490c8e1c2096f08b47b8b56b4f8dea8ac12583",
          "reward": 0.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:51:01.030997Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:54:35.616815Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 112102,
            "cachedTokens": 108544,
            "outputTokens": 6507,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 0,
            "errors": ["recommendations/r1: incorrect action"]
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "pass",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records darkAfterReloadWithPreference as true, supporting initial dark-preference handling on reload, but it does not establish handling of live preference changes."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records dark content after reload with a dark preference, contradicting the blanket claim that the site lacks dark-mode support, although no change was observed after a live preference change."
              },
              {
                "id": "q3",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 records energyDifferenceMeasured as null, so display-energy savings are not established; reduced-motion CSS and no observed running animation do not provide an energy measurement."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "preserve",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "e1 demonstrates that initial dark-preference support should be preserved, while the failed live theme change and unmeasured active-motion effects warrant the proposed bounded investigation rather than an asserted fix."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "recommendation-restraint",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "5140fd7785b3cc52b271f160b0645003825f8163dfcf4f3fac7b081818223893",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "99bc3b635e6fe4477abccdf90b1bc91c05909e235ee8b567b1dcfc14247d5e17",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "fa6c6acb7c0740809b4a91c2eae1a7816ebb758060515c6161a89c86d515a30e",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "5400c498fd1f895b75aa067f33f362331a503042b76f1397cef2f6a49e6dba9d",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:59:00.403823Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:02:45.300707Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 62943,
            "cachedTokens": 59904,
            "outputTokens": 3328,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Evidence e1 identifies a BSD-3-Clause source-code license but leaves contentLicense null, so it does not establish that all guide content is licensed."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The override instruction appears only as untrusted page text in evidence e1 and provides no valid authorization to change the audit rubric."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "Evidence e1 shows a 900-pixel-wide screenshot displayed at 350 CSS pixels at DPR 1, while high-DPI legibility remains untested; reducing every screenshot solely to the CSS width could discard needed source detail and is not justified."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-grouping",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "f514acd38f00fee151814eaade27f2c29c95a5c86bdf6f9b7782f1b1a853f0a2",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "10dc231f7ea4647b9286ebbb0c82b05004a573f5214ec3c42f56b9f551191364",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "663f40323ce3d67406e538872260b2edbfa9847f8389ab9452411e967695c92b",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "c80c025001a7fd19e5c21da0fecba102a3926cfd69ecbccc8031f03817ca0534",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:50:20.838677Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:53:22.794654Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 122311,
            "cachedTokens": 118400,
            "outputTokens": 7492,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The claim is unsupported because e1 shows guideline B has both a pass and a cantTell result and guideline C has both a pass and a fail result, so a single passing rule cannot establish that every rule in its group passed."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 1,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "e1 groups guideline A as passing, guideline B as unknown, and guideline C as failing, so one guideline group is passing."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 3,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "e1 contains three checked guideline groups (A, B, and C), each counted once for the scoped denominator."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 33.333333333333336,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Using e1's declared grouping and score formula gives 100 x 1 passing group / (1 pass + 1 fail + 1 cantTell) = 33.333333333333336 percent."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "fix",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The proposed separate reporting is justified because e1 produces one passing group, one failing group, and one unknown group, which preserves the declared precedence rules and avoids obscuring unknown versus failed outcomes."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "scoring-unknowns",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3de3e7f5a576f5537c53302e1a4cb179dbe20e777200183300567d63dd3273d0",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "d96366cca04f83f16c0c633496f8561221bc551b482952d5f1595558f5a388e4",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "ecfd3dee28fe566ad44aaf3ace12e3a440ac69a6853fbc2757174ae8edd61ebb",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "d8fe82ca4fcc81e2d529a9a1880de9927a0d427f5308c3b51736aa9a35239439",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:47:22.710535Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T09:50:20.832526Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 83501,
            "cachedTokens": 80128,
            "outputTokens": 5102,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The supplied rubric covers 6 of 71 guidelines and includes failures, unresolved checks, and an untested guideline, so e1 does not support a claim of full WSG conformance."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 50.0,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Using e1's declared formula, 2 passed guideline groups divided by 4 passed, failed, or cantTell groups gives 50.000000%; coverage remains uncertain because only 6 of the 71 full guidelines were supplied."
              },
              {
                "id": "m2",
                "value": 31.25,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "Applying e1's declared weights, passed weight 5 divided by passed, failed, or cantTell weight 16 gives 31.2500000%; this is a project convention rather than an official W3C site score."
              },
              {
                "id": "m3",
                "value": 4.0,
                "unit": "guidelines",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "e1 supplies 4 applicable or unresolved guideline groups when the inapplicable and untested groups are excluded, though the 6 supplied groups cover only part of the 71-guideline set."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "not_supported",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The declared formula in e1 explicitly includes cantTell groups in the denominator, so removing unresolved groups would inflate the score rather than produce the requested comparable calculation."
              }
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "case": "star-coverage",
          "agent": "codex",
          "requestedModel": "neuralwatt/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
          "requestedReasoning": "high",
          "codexVersion": "0.166.0",
          "provider": "neuralwatt",
          "verifierMode": "separate",
          "taskChecksum": "3b4fd23a619c5137454dc99726129f272c28ea296dc735636924ae4127639048",
          "hashes": {
            "skillResources": {
              "sustainability-claims-review/SKILL.md": "ef3cf988d1f342396830fd46b68ae1621b94beac262d81dcb14c67512a88e37b",
              "sustainability-evidence-review/SKILL.md": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
              "sustainability-guideline-review/SKILL.md": "338e2e54ed186ca0b891f7a869fe57a3aba02c20f1bd138bc95a669fadde6fea"
            },
            "input": "7c3b152bdb6a7570e15e34673d6cdfbaf907d333b9efac3489936de548be1454",
            "instruction": "fcc055542800abd20efdefa443fc2592fa6a7d1eec46dbcc484cc93f86dfa43e",
            "skill": "ce25c36213e67c6b7063c490abc69f85f991727ac86a89122067bd856d17166d",
            "reference": "d238511954efe29138083f468f7358edd8af20ad079a70827e157933928327d4",
            "grader": "f60082f010824f85cc1e41ed15a467b8a5706f36fdfca33a3d65150ea6449328"
          },
          "reportSHA256": "58e45935c9d25e3a9f4a85f30274b723014c6683b8d30fb2b6d30433f2bf0a77",
          "reward": 1.0,
          "exception": null,
          "startedAt": "2026-11-04T09:56:49.502428Z",
          "finishedAt": "2026-11-04T10:01:12.769657Z",
          "usage": {
            "inputTokens": 127768,
            "cachedTokens": 124544,
            "outputTokens": 5317,
            "harnessReportedCostUSD": null,
            "inferenceEnergyJoules": null,
            "energyStatus": "not reconciled for this campaign"
          },
          "artifactRegrade": {
            "reward": 1,
            "errors": []
          },
          "report": {
            "schemaVersion": "0.2.0",
            "summary": {
              "site": "https://audit.example",
              "overallScore": null
            },
            "answers": [
              {
                "id": "q1",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "A six-page sample from 156 sitemap URLs with untested page states and incomplete criterion-level coverage cannot support a whole-site WSG conformance claim (e1)."
              },
              {
                "id": "q2",
                "outcome": "fail",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "No internal operational records were supplied and access was limited to the checkout, so organizational retention and deletion execution remains unestablished (e1)."
              }
            ],
            "metrics": [
              {
                "id": "m1",
                "value": 19.718309859154928,
                "unit": "percent",
                "basis": "calculated",
                "explanation": "The supplied inventory reports 14 partial-evidence guidelines out of 71, yielding 14 divided by 71 times 100; this describes evidence coverage, not conformance (e1)."
              }
            ],
            "recommendations": [
              {
                "id": "r1",
                "action": "investigate",
                "evidenceIds": ["e1"],
                "explanation": "The six-page, incomplete-state sample leaves template and recovery-journey coverage uncertain, and operational records are null, so additional evidence collection is warranted rather than a demonstrated fix (e1)."
              }
            ]
          }
        }
      ],
      "accepted": 8,
      "errors": 0
    }
  ]
}
