{
  "site": "https://wagtail.org",
  "packetSHA256": "47b3fdce5a851635c8998be4df9b404f75a7baac75c6744e0db468f45c47483e",
  "reviewer": {
    "harness": "Codex CLI 0.166.0",
    "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
    "reasoning": "low"
  },
  "rows": [
    {
      "checkId": "distraction",
      "guideline": "2.5",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Desktop text includes an event promotion and cookie prompt alongside the reading tasks; recorded dialogs are hidden and the homepage video is paused without autoplay. Geometry and text do not resolve the prompts' visual disruption.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect initial viewport screenshots and observe dismissal while completing the reading task."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "choice",
      "guideline": "2.6",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "staged.json:runs:0", "staged.json:runs:1", "staged.json:runs:2", "staged.json:runs:3", "staged.json:runs:4", "staged.json:runs:5"],
      "rationale": "The cookie prompt explains measurement and exposes 'Opt in' and 'Opt out'; homepage controls have equal 319×57 geometry. All six branch clicks completed, but visual prominence, persisted choice and subsequent tracking behavior are not established.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Compare button appearance and verify stored consent and tracking after each choice."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "comprehension",
      "guideline": "2.7",
      "outcome": "fail",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Sustainability desktop text calls 12 tCO2e/year the average for 6431 sites totaling 5173 tons/year; these figures cannot describe the same population and average. Digital emissions more clearly separates its homepage estimate, April 2026 date and method. The contradictory ecosystem wording impairs the declared claims-reading task.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Trace the ecosystem figures to their source and clarify the population, statistic and period."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "consistency",
      "guideline": "2.8",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Desktop text and controls repeat Project, Explore, Developers, Community, Support, Get started and Open the search across all three pages. This supports sampled naming consistency, not a complete design system.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Compare the opened navigation controls across the three pages."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "motion",
      "guideline": "2.10",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Desktop animation snapshots are quiet, but reduced_motion records five running one-iteration animations on the homepage and one on Sustainability. Target tags and current times do not establish motion purpose or visible effect. The homepage video has native controls and no autoplay.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Identify the recorded animation properties and observe their purpose and reduced-motion treatment."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "notifications",
      "guideline": "2.12",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Recorded states show zero notification permission request calls; observed dialogs are hidden. Newsletter signup is explicitly offered rather than automatically enabled. This pass covers these anonymous states only; browser permission was already denied.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Repeat the reading journey with notification permission unset."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "documents",
      "guideline": "2.13",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Print states hide navigation and retain task text; download inventories are empty. DOM visibility does not establish usable pagination, unclipped charts or efficient printed output, and no downloadable document was inspected.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect a print preview of the Sustainability and Digital emissions pages."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "unused-code",
      "guideline": "3.2",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2", "source.json:files:8"],
      "rationale": "codeCoverage captures initial load plus 500 ms and includes unexecuted ranges, not demonstrated dead code. Candidate webpack.config.js uses production mode, cssnano and compressed Sass, but representative interaction coverage and deployment correspondence are missing.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Extend coverage through navigation, search, consent and media activation before considering removal."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "components",
      "guideline": "3.3",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "source.json:files:9", "source.json:files:11"],
      "rationale": "Initial resources include main.js; candidate base.html loads it globally, and site-search-desktop.js imports MicroModal for click-triggered search. Neither a deployed module attribution nor usable deferred activation is demonstrated, so splitting is not yet justified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Map the deployed main bundle to components and exercise search before comparing a deferred candidate."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "layout",
      "guideline": "3.10",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "All pages report document width 1290 at a 1280 viewport and 370 at a 360 viewport. Narrow states retain task text and expose mobile controls, but those controls were not exercised and the 10-pixel overflow's effect on task content is unresolved.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Locate the overflowing element and complete the footer journey using the narrow navigation."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "impact-choice",
      "guideline": "5.4",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "The homepage offers optional video playback and a theme switch. Sustainability explains an OLED-related dark-mode benefit, while Digital emissions explains its static measurement approach. The evidence does not establish contextual impact information at the video decision or its usefulness; labels on every control are not required.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect the video activation context for duration, data expectations and a useful reading alternative."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "journeys",
      "guideline": "2.4",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:journeys:0"],
      "rationale": "The sustainability-footer journey actually clicked footer a[href=\"/sustainability/\"]. The final URL is /sustainability/, document status is 200, and URL, selector and Sustainability text postconditions all succeeded. This establishes the declared route, not optimal usability.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Repeat the same task with keyboard navigation."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "media-delivery",
      "guideline": "2.9",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1"],
      "rationale": "Sustainability includes a 1300-pixel-wide WebP chart rendered 660 pixels wide on desktop, alongside smaller images enlarged to 660 pixels. Several images lack srcset; this alone is not failure. Chart readability, intended pixel densities and candidate rendition quality were not assessed.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Compare the chart and enlarged images visually at narrow and desktop sizes at intended pixel densities."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "font-delivery",
      "guideline": "2.11",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "document.fonts records Kumbh Sans 400 and 700 loaded, 600 unloaded, with display block for 400 and auto for the others. Body styling declares a sans-serif fallback; two WOFF2 responses are 19304 and 19640 bytes. Constrained-loading readability and required language coverage remain unknown.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Block font responses and verify readable task text during loading and after fallback."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "semantic-forms",
      "guideline": "3.6",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Each desktop document declares en, one main and one H1, and visible controls have text, labels or aria-labels. However, heading inventories truncate at 100 entries before exposing the primary heading, leaving its semantic correspondence to task content unverified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Capture the actual H1 and main contents, and resolve naming references for activated dialogs."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "metadata",
      "guideline": "3.8",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "All three pages have descriptive titles and exact-page HTTPS canonicals. The homepage's WebPage and Organization blocks parse as JSON; other pages declare none. Digital emissions lacks a description, which is not mandatory for this scoped expectation.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Validate the homepage structured data against its intended vocabulary if reuse requires it."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "preference-behavior",
      "guideline": "3.9",
      "outcome": "fail",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "On every page, live_dark matches dark preference but retains dark text on a white background; cold_dark instead uses white text on rgb(38,38,38). Task text remains available. The contrast between initialization and live change demonstrates an unmet live preference expectation; animation purpose remains separately unresolved.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Verify live system-theme changes with no explicit site override, including the intended precedence of the theme switch."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "no-js-content",
      "guideline": "2.17",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Fresh no_javascript states retain the homepage introduction, sustainability commitments, emissions method and repeated navigation text. Core reading survives without scripts; this does not establish search or every interactive control.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Follow the Sustainability link in the no-JavaScript state."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "api-requests",
      "guideline": "3.11",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Initial network records contain /sitewide_alert/ and multiple analytics pageview requests, including distinct UA-112981-50 and UA-112981-56 destinations. Similar URLs do not prove redundancy; destination purpose, freshness requirements and longer-window behavior are unknown.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Explain the analytics destinations and observe requests through consent and an idle interval."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "public-cache-policy",
      "guideline": "4.2",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Versioned main CSS, blocking/main scripts and WOFF2 responses expose public immutable max-age=315360000 plus ETag and Last-Modified. These are appropriate reusable-asset policies in the sample; headers do not establish measured browser reuse or offline operation.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Perform a warm navigation and verify intended asset reuse."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "text-compression",
      "guideline": "4.3",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Successful page HTML responses use br; main CSS and main/blocking JavaScript use gzip. For example, main CSS is 21060 encoded versus 125698 decoded bytes. The Plausible 404 and tiny analytics responses do not overturn this material-text finding.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Verify compression remains enabled after the next asset deployment."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "keyboard-path",
      "guideline": "3.6",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Twelve-step traces reach the promotion, skip link, homepage, navigation, search and task links in a meaningful order. Steps report visible geometry, focusVisible=true and 1px auto outlines, but the rendered indicator's discernibility is not directly demonstrated.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect focused screenshots for the skip link, navigation and search control."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "disclosure-scope",
      "guideline": "2.1",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["staged.json:discovery:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2", "disclosures.json:sites:0"],
      "rationale": "Retrieved Sustainability explicitly includes reducing wagtail.org impacts; Digital emissions identifies this site's homepage, April 2026 estimate, SWD v4 inputs and monitoring approach. This satisfies disclosure scope without verifying execution or the reported quantities; the ecosystem arithmetic needs clarification.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Obtain the underlying measurement and monitoring records for the published claims."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "carbon-discovery",
      "guideline": "3.13",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["staged.json:discovery:0", "disclosures.json:sites:0"],
      "rationale": "Root /carbon.txt returns 200 without redirects and parses with declared version 0.4. Exact-host disclosure URLs are usable and retrieved; provider service relationships are declared. The common-field review reports no structural issues but does not validate schema conformance; expired 2023/2024 declarations remain historical evidence.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Validate against an authoritative version-specific schema and review historical validity annotations."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "hosting-evidence",
      "guideline": "4.1",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["staged.json:discovery:0", "disclosures.json:sites:0", "source.json:files:3"],
      "rationale": "carbon.txt declares Cloudflare CDN, Heroku platform/database/cache, AWS object storage and GitHub CI/CD. Candidate README also says Heroku hosting. These statements do not independently corroborate current origin infrastructure or its operational environmental scope.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Obtain origin-linked infrastructure records and current provider energy evidence for those services."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-reuse",
      "guideline": "3.4",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:9", "source.json:files:10"],
      "rationale": "Candidate header.html invokes the same main_navigation tag for desktop and mobile, and includes shared skip-link and search components; base.html includes shared SVG sprites. This supports selected interface reuse at clean revision 9fa65385f27c15b83c86a4f6e0e3ac18d4784609, not project-wide efficiency or deployed identity.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect the shared navigation implementation and confirm the deployed revision before proposing changes."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-dependencies",
      "guideline": "3.12",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:0", "source.json:files:1", "source.json:files:2", "source.json:files:4", "source.json:files:7"],
      "rationale": "pyproject.toml and package.json enumerate dependencies; Dockerfile invokes npm ci and Poetry installation. package-lock.json and poetry.lock are metadata-only, so valid, compatible resolutions cannot be established. Checkout revision 9fa65385 is clean; installed and deployed versions remain unverified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Expose lock headers and dependency resolution entries, then verify a frozen install."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-runtime",
      "guideline": "3.15",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:0", "source.json:files:4", "source.json:files:5", "source.json:files:6"],
      "rationale": "At clean candidate revision 9fa65385, pyproject requires Python ^3.14, Docker uses Python 3.14 and CI selects 3.14. Node 24 agrees across Docker and .nvmrc, which CI reads; Poetry 2.4.0 agrees between Docker and CI. This is declaration consistency only: deployment and latest-stable status are unverified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Confirm deployed runtime versions; capture authoritative release evidence only if making a latest-stable claim."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-automation",
      "guideline": "4.6",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:6"],
      "rationale": "Selected ci.yml declares push triggers for main/next and pull requests, with workflow/ref concurrency and cancel-in-progress=true. Test jobs depend on lint and dependency caches are keyed by relevant files. Superseded-run control supports this narrow check at clean candidate revision 9fa65385; execution and deployment are unverified.",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "nextEvidence": "Inspect one superseded run and the lint configuration before asserting duplicated validation."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-maintenance",
      "guideline": "5.10",
      "outcome": "pass",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:3", "source.json:files:6"],
      "rationale": "README documents Docker/Vagrant setup, migrations, cache setup, frontend builds, linting and deployment branches; ci.yml declares system checks, migration checks and tests. This is sufficient maintenance documentation in clean candidate revision 9fa65385, without proving execution, staffing or deployment identity.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Verify the documented setup and maintenance commands against a current maintainer workflow."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-change-docs",
      "guideline": "5.12",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:12", "source.json:files:3"],
      "rationale": "Selected CHANGELOG.md is unavailable and README explains development rather than versioned user-facing changes. This bounded selection does not prove change documentation is absent elsewhere. Candidate revision 9fa65385 is clean; deployed correspondence remains unknown.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Supply the project's actual release notes or equivalent user-facing change history."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-budgets",
      "guideline": "5.24",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:8", "source.json:files:3", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "rationale": "Selected webpack.config.js has no explicit relevant asset limit and exceedance action; its development statistics setting disables performance output. Digital emissions claims weekly monitoring and alerts but gives no concrete target. These selections do not establish project-wide absence; candidate deployment is unverified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Supply the configured page-weight threshold and its alert or build-failure behavior."
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-open-source",
      "guideline": "5.25",
      "outcome": "cantTell",
      "evidenceIds": ["source.json:files:0", "source.json:files:1", "source.json:files:3"],
      "rationale": "Candidate manifests declare BSD-3-Clause and ISC respectively; README links the repository and explains setup. No selected license or contribution document resolves reuse scope and contribution procedure. This is a selection gap at clean revision 9fa65385, not proof of missing project policy; deployment remains unverified.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "nextEvidence": "Read the applicable LICENSE and contribution guidance, resolving the manifest license scopes."
    }
  ],
  "topFindings": [
    {
      "checkId": "comprehension",
      "title": "Clarify the ecosystem emissions figures",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "summary": "The Sustainability page presents 5173 tons/year across 6431 sites alongside a 12-ton average, without distinguishing populations. These figures cannot describe the same average. The separate homepage estimate has a clearer method and date.",
      "recommendation": "Check the underlying ecosystem analysis and correct or qualify the population, statistic and period. Preserve the separate website-method disclosure and avoid presenting published estimates as verified measurements.",
      "priority": "high"
    },
    {
      "checkId": "preference-behavior",
      "title": "Make live theme changes follow the intended preference",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2", "source.json:files:9"],
      "summary": "Cold dark-mode navigation changes colors on all three pages, while live dark-mode changes leave the light palette. Reading content remains available. Candidate base.html identifies theme initialization, but the deployed implementation is not established.",
      "recommendation": "Confirm explicit-choice precedence, then test and correct live system-theme handling where no override exists. Preserve working cold initialization and the manual switch; treat source locations as candidates until deployment is matched.",
      "priority": "medium"
    },
    {
      "checkId": "layout",
      "title": "Resolve the repeated overflow and mobile task gap",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1", "probes.json:pages:2"],
      "summary": "All sampled pages exceed both desktop and narrow viewport widths by 10 pixels. The packet does not establish whether this clips useful content, and mobile controls were not exercised.",
      "recommendation": "Identify the overflowing element and complete the sustainability journey at 360 pixels before selecting a fix. Preserve retained reading content and responsive navigation.",
      "priority": "medium"
    },
    {
      "checkId": "media-delivery",
      "title": "Validate media quality before changing renditions",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:0", "probes.json:pages:1"],
      "summary": "The Sustainability chart is delivered as a 1300-pixel WebP at a 660-pixel desktop width, while some smaller images are enlarged. Neither excessive delivery nor adequate readability is established by dimensions alone.",
      "recommendation": "Compare chart and image readability at intended sizes and pixel densities before proposing responsive renditions. Preserve WebP delivery and the homepage video's controlled, non-autoplay behavior; verify activation before claiming deferral benefits.",
      "priority": "low"
    },
    {
      "checkId": "source-budgets",
      "title": "Expose the concrete monitoring budget",
      "evidenceIds": ["probes.json:pages:2", "source.json:files:8", "source.json:files:3"],
      "summary": "The public page describes weekly checks and alerts, but selected evidence supplies no explicit threshold or exceedance procedure. This does not establish that budgets are absent.",
      "recommendation": "Capture the existing monitoring threshold and response procedure first. If missing, propose a task-informed budget as a source candidate, verify deployment correspondence, and validate enforcement before calling it a production fix.",
      "priority": "low"
    }
  ]
}